Sunday, September 15, 2013

My Critical Perspective Use


Learning about the different ways to analyze a literary work, I realize how few perspectives I use when deciding if I like a book or not. One of the ways I do use when analyzing a text is the formalist perspective. If it takes too much effort to decipher what the author is trying to say, I usually will turn away from the book. I like a book that is easy to read, yet uses sophisticated literary devices. For example, in Sula, there were several parts in the book where I became confused as to what was happening. This was because some of the words or the order of the plot confused me, resulting in frustration. Over the course of Sula, there were a few of these muddled areas where I was disoriented about the plot thus leading to a general dislike of Toni Morrison’s novel.

Formalism is really the only perspective I use when reading books. I don’t think about what time period the novel was written in or what mental state the author was in when they wrote it. Those things just don’t occur to me when I read. I may think about how an author’s past experiences affect the plot or characters after I read the book if I find out a fact about them but I would never research the author beforehand and draw the connections while reading the book. I just read the book, and if I like it, I like it! As simple as that! I guess that’s why not many of my favorite books are in the literary canon.

 Perspective Notes

Psychoanalytic Perspective
·      Based on Freud’s psychoanalysis
·      The conscious and unconscious
·      Driven by sexual and aggressive desires: animalistic impulses
·      Literary works are linked with the author’s mental and emotional characteristics
·      Try to explain how a literary work reflects its writer’s consciousness and mental world
·      Superego is the parent and represses the Id, which is all of the impulses. The Ego balances the two

Marxist Perspective
·      Focuses on how dominant elites exploit subordinate groups
·      Struggle from the people on the bottom to get to the top

Feminist Perspective
·      Focuses on what the literary work reveals about the role, position, and influence of women
·      See literature as an arena in which to contest for power
·      Literature is an agent for social transformation
·      Takes into account the patriarchal culture at the time of the text
·      What was the role of males and females when the book was written?

Reader- Response Perspective
·      Where does the literary meaning reside? In the literary text, in the reader, or in the interactive space between the text and reader?
·      Must think of the literary work objectively
·      Don’t just base the book on like or dislike
·      For a reader to connect to the book, the reader must find their identity themes within the text
·      Reader’s personal understanding
·      How did you feel upon first reading it? What emotions do you have?

Mythological Perspective
·      Archetypes
·      Patterns of human action and experience throughout time and space
·      The Mentor, The Rebel, The Innocent
·      Universal experiences = birth, death, rites of passage, sex, etc.
·      Not about myths like Greek gods and dragons

Structuralism Perspective
·      Everything is based on symbols
·      We ascribed meaning to symbols based on context
·      Looks at differences
·      We look at symbols based on differences
·      BINARY OPPOSITION, things that are opposed to each other

Deconstructive Perspective
·      Looks for differences in meaning within the context
·      There is never a clear message due to the instability of the language
·      Message is not consistent, hypocrisy
·      Believe language is self destroying and self contradicting
·      What oppositions exist in the work? What elements suggest a contradiction?
·      Nobody is perfect, that’s why there is contradiction in the text

Cultural Studies Perspective
·      Looks at text from the perspective of marginalized cultures
·      Focuses on the experiences of outcast groups throughout history
·      Asian, African-American, homosexual, etc.

No comments:

Post a Comment